Skip to main content

table of contents
Inferno XIX Circle Eight (The Simoniacs)
This is the canto that Dante famously condemns Pope Nicholas III to damnation and hints that Boniface VIII will serve a similar fate. The sinners here have traded religious favors or positions for worldly riches. The sinners in this circle are stuck upside down so only their feet face flames.
- It is interesting that Longfellow and Sayers choose to reference “St John” for the English translation and Ciardi, Mandelbaum and Palma use the Italian version “San Giovanni”.
- In Canto 19. 52 each translator addresses Boniface’s transgression but each translator’s description paints a different picture and intensity of the sin. Palma’s is probably the closest to the financial wrong doing that Dante was accusing Boniface of but Sayers and Mandelbaum present a very emotional response
Annotate
Side-by-Side Comparisons